Monday, March 9, 2015

Discussion- The Farming of Bones

Arline O’Hearon, Dananir Arafat, Hilton Weeks


Chapter Summaries:

Chapter 30:

This chapter starts off after Amabelle and Yves cross the river and witness Odette and Wilner's deaths. They were found by a priest and a young doctor who were looking for survivors along the riverbank. The priest and the doctor take Amabelle and Yves to a clinic where they take care of Amabelle. While in the clinic, Amabelle has a dream about her mother rising above the river that she drowned in. In her dream, her mother reassures Amabelle that she loves her and has always loved her and that she is going to be okay. In the clinic, Amabelle listens the stories of others about what had happened to them. One man in particular says “I felt like my woman on our first night together”. This man was struck my a machete and ended up in a pile of corpses. When he awoke, he said he felt like his woman on their first night together because his wife woke up in the middle of night and started screaming because she had forgotten where she had been. Amabelle is in and out of sleep for days because of her fever and doesn't have any sense of time when she finally wakes up. The nun asks Amabelle who the man was that came to take care of her everyday and Amabelle assumes it was Sabastein but then finds out it was actually Yves. Yves has been looking everywhere for Sebastien and Mimi but hasn't had any luck so far. Yves goes and visits Amabelle and tells her that he is going back to his land and asks her if she wants to come. Amabelle nods her head yes and when Yves comes back the next day, he tells Amabelle that his will take her to Sebastien's house and she will be reunited with him and Mimi. On page 217 Amabelle says “I looked for my face in the tin ceiling above me as I waited for Yves to return. With everyone lying face up and with their bodies so close together, I couldn't tell which face was mine.” This quote shows how the clinic is filling up with more people but also the fact the Amabelle doesn't recognize herself anymore after everything that has happened.

Chapter 31:

Yves and Amabelle leave the clinic in a camión (a bus) and go to the Cap. The Cap is described as “an old new city” and “a city burnt to the ground many times for its own salvation”. After they get off the bus, Amabelle and Yves walk past shops while the shopkeepers and merchants stared at them and knew where they came from just by looking at them. When they reach the cathedral, a woman gives Amabelle an orange and gives her instructions to warm it over a fire, rub on her body and take a bath to help heal her scars and bruises. Amabelle and Yves make it to Yves' mother's house and she greets them. When they first arrive, Yves's mother thinks that Amabelle is Yves' “woman”. On page 224, Amabelle remembers what her father used to say “Misery won't touch you gentle. It always leaves its thumbprints on you; sometimes it leaves them for others to see, sometimes for nobody but you to know of.”

Chapter 32:

Yves' mother moves his six cousins out of his old bedroom so him and Amabelle can share the bed. While Amabelle is sitting on the bed, she overhears Yves' mother asking him who she is and where her people are. Yves says nothing. Amabelle goes outside to the yard to bath herself with the orange and hears the courtyard children giggling at her. She then says, “In spite of their curiosity, I knew that my body could no longer be a tempting spectacle, nor would I ever be truly young or beautiful, if I ever had been. Now my flesh was simply a map of scars and bruises, a marred testament.” The next morning, Yves' mother walks up to Amabelle, kisses her on the forehead and tells her that she knows her story. Yves spends his days in the field planting even though his mother tells him that it isn't the right season. While Yves is working in the field and his mother is visiting a friend, Amabelle asks around and finds out where Sebastien, Mimi and their mother lived. Amabelle pays a boy in mint candy to take her to the house. When they get to the house, their was no activity other than a girl rushing in and out of the yard, carrying jugs of water on her head. Amabelle walks by the house everyday to see if Sebastien and Mimi show up. Thinking of Sebastien worries Amabelle that he would will recognize her if he ever saw her again.

Chapter 33:

Weeks go by and Yves and Amabelle have formed a routine; settling into a quiet companionship. Yves works in his father’s fields all day and Amabelle only sees him at night. While in bed one night Yves tells her that officials are giving out money to the survivors from the Generalissimo. Although he gives them restitution he does not admit guilt. They both agree to go the next morning; when they arrive there are over a thousand people from all over waiting to tell their stories. The badly injured and pregnant are permitted first. Yves and Amabelle wait for sixteen days and on the sixteenth day Man Denise shows up but unfortunately they announce that they will no longer be giving out money. This outrages the crowd and they end up charging the entrance looking for someone to hear them out. Yves and Amabelle end up taking Man Denise back to her home. Amabelle ends up staying the night with her; she finds out a bit about Sebastien’s past. Man Denise also informs her that she has heard that her children were killed.
Chapter 34:
Amabelle returns to Yves house and discovers that Yves has told his mother the reason that there is no love between the two of them. Yves tries to forget the past by focusing on the future but Amabelle can’t do that and fears she may never. While in bed with Yves he tells her that he would have died if it weren’t for Joel; he pushed him out of the way of the car. He isn’t exactly a coward, just self-preserving. He could never save another person’s life if it meant his own. He hid when he saw Sebastien and Mimi. Amabelle feels she may have killed Odette in the river on accident and Yves tells her that she died when Wilner died. She is grateful for this and the two end up “sleeping” together that night.
Chapter 35:
Amabelle goes back to Man Denise’s house the next afternoon only to find out that she has gone back to Port-au-Prince. She ends up at afternoon mass at Cap’s Cathedral. She speaks with a woman, the two discuss their pasts and where they come from. She waits until after mass to talk to Father Emil. At first he thinks she is there to tell her tale which they have stopped doing. Amabelle asks if he has heard of Father Romain or Father Vargas. She finds out they are still alive and that Father Romain is living near the border.
Chapter 36:
In chapter 36 Amabelle was focused on going and visiting father Romain, for answers and for information. She travels across the border to see father Romain but to her surprise, father Romain doesn't remember who she is, or remember anything important to that matter. He’s been subjected to old age and the torture he experienced years ago when he was trapped. The drool, and the uneasiness of his eyes were clear indications of his mental state, which was not in good standing. Amabelle proceed to question father Romain about the whereabouts and history of Mimi and Sabastian. Unable to give Amabelle a clear answer, he mumbles on about things unrelated to what Amabelle asked. Though he starts speaking about the history about how his country was invaded by outsiders, by far too many outsiders. He ends up saying that dominicans must have separate traditions and own ways of living, if not soon they will assimilate into Haitians. The conversation ended with a farewell from Amabelle and a greeting from father Romain. Another example of how severe father Romain’s mental state is.
Chapter 37:
Chapter 37 was a reflection on Amabelle’s feelings on her past, how it was hurtful time for her. She's thinks about all that happened, how it could've gone different.


Discussion Questions:

(Chapter 33, page 242) 
When you know you’re going to die, you try to be near the bones of your own people. You don’t even think you have bones when you’re young, even when you break them, you don’t believe you have them.  But when you’re old, they start reminding you they’re there. They start turning to dust on you, even as you’re walking here and there, going from place to place”

How does this quote relate to the role of bodies in the novel?

(Chapter 31, page 224-225) 
“I remembered what my father used to say as he would hurry off with a knapsack of bottles filled with leaves and warm rum, as he raced to a birth or to a death, thinking of ways to encourage of halt the event. 'Misery won't touch you gentle. It always leaves its thumbprints on you; sometimes it leaves them for others to see, sometimes for nobody but you to know of.'”

Misery plays a big role in the novel. It seems that every character in the book is dealing with some kind of pain or misery. Why do you think Danticat chose to add this quote at this particular part of the chapter?

(Chapter 36, page 260) 
They once came here only to cut sugarcane, but now there are more of them than there will ever be cane to cut, you understand?

What do you think of this, and do you think this is a  clear representation of what happened to their country?


Contextual Material:





Father Romains symptoms such as Trouble concentrating, emotionally numb,Trying to avoid thinking or talking about the traumatic event, relates to the symptoms of PTSD. 










No comments:

Post a Comment